Manitoba Election Debate Heats Up: Health Care, Taxes and Accusations Take Centre Stage


As the Manitoba provincial election fast approaches on October 3rd, the stage was set for a televised debate where leaders of the three main political parties thoroughly examined topical issues ranging from health care to the cost of living. The one-hour showdown took place on Thursday night, harboring crucial implications for the electoral performance of the participating leaders.

Wab Kinew, the leader of the New Democratic Party (NDP), who currently is spearheading the race according to prevailing opinion polls, was a common object of disagreement for the other two leaders. Kinew found himself on the defensive as Progressive Conservative Leader Heather Stefanson took her shots at him for allegedly pledging $3 billion in additional expenditures. This, Stefanson argued, would necessitate an increase in the provincial sales tax, following the echoes of the previous NDP government, which elevated the tax in 2013 before being overthrown in the subsequent elections. Kinew, while responding, flatly denied the accusations, asserting, “I will never raise the PST.”

Follow us on Google News! ✔️

Stefanson cast the first stone, posing a directed question at Kinew regarding his vow to explore the Prairie Green Landfill, where, reportedly, the remains of two indigenous women, Morgan Harris and Marcedes Myran, are likely located. She pointed out that despite a feasibility study asserting the possibility of such exploration, the risk of exposure to hazardous materials like asbestos was a major concern. She boldly asked, “Why are you willing to put $184 million and Manitoba workers at risk without a guarantee?”

In his defense, Kinew accused Stefanson of stoking divisions with wedge issues, stating that he was prepared to balance respect and dignity for the affected families, along with financial responsibility. He added, “But what I won’t do is use wedge politics to try and score a few political points.”

A large part of the debate saw Kinew and Stefanson locking horns over healthcare, particularly the downgrade of emergency departments in three Winnipeg hospitals to urgent care facilities. But amidst these exchanges, Stefanson strategically turned to Liberal Leader Dougald Lamont in an apparent move to indirectly attack Kinew. Lamont, whose party presently holds three of the 57 legislature seats, seized the opportunity to express his political philosophy.

Accusing Kinew of abandonment of key NDP principles, Lamont aimed to position his party as the real contender against the Conservative government. He stated, “We’re the only party that wants to change things,” portraying a confident stance despite a downward tilt in his party’s recent opinion polls.

The debate culminated in Kinew reaching out to Liberal supporters, urging them to extend their support to NDP in the forthcoming elections. He had previously begun his campaign by unveiling a personal endorsement letter from Lloyd Axworthy, a former federal Liberal cabinet minister. The appeal, as it stands, crystalizes the competition and tensity in the ongoing electoral campaign.