Looking for the best cookies in the West Island? We got you.

4
7088
West Island Cookies
Image by Pezibear from Pixabay

Best West Island Cookies

Cookies, Cookies, Cookies.  So many cookies, so little time! The West Island is a place where cookies come to be home-baked. It was a real chore working on this post tasting all these cookies (wink wink). I was forced to try various cookies from local bakers, it’s sad, I know. From traditional to crunchy, to soft, to decorated – we have it all in the West. Pick up or delivery, here is a guide that will help you shop local and be very happy that you did.

We polled our Facebook followers to see where they order their homemade cookies, this is what they answered:

1Biscuits Milk & Cookies

A sugar cookie with any design you can conjure!! What What What? I asked for a sample of each cookie baker on my list in order to be able to truly tell you how I feel about my choices.  This beautiful cookie arrived with my logo on it.  It was a tasty treat, sweet icing and of course a stunning look. I hope to have these bad boys at an event as a giveaway.
email: biscuitsmilkandcookies@gmail.com
Facebook: Biscuitsmilkandcookies

2Hey Sugar Cookies

Hey Sugar Nutella Cookie, where to order cookies in the West island

After baking chocolate chip cookies for the ”Help Save Matthew” cause in February 2017, friends and family were encouraging this baker to start a chocolate chip cookie business! Later that year, Hey Sugar was born. Her favourite baking ingredient may be Nutella. The soft and chewy Chocolate Chunk Nutella Swirl cookie was perfect for my party. This cookie is soft and chocolaty but not too chocolaty if you know what I mean.  Smooth and melty even long after it is out of the oven. I tasted the classic semi-sweet chocolate chip version that was classically delicious. The cookies arrived in a nice baker box, cute for gift giving. Liane has a big heart in the community and often includes local donations on her menu. She also creates cookie pies for all occasions.  A portion of sales are donated to local charities.
email: heysugarcookies@gmail.com
Facebook: HeySugar

3My Sweet Tooth Cookies

Best West Island Cookies

Chocolate chip cookies, chocolate cookies with white chocolate chips, white chocolate & Macadamia nut cookies all with the option of a piece of a chocolate bar in the Center such as Caramilk, Kit Kat, Reese’s Cup, Toblerone, Wunderbar.
They also have some decadent squares that are quite popular:
Slutty Brownies
Signature Squares

4Rossi Assistants

Lilly Rossie Cookies West Island

Lilly Rossi will not only tantalize your taste buds but she will WOW you with her gift-giving presentation.  Lilly’s mission is to take the stress out of your life by reducing your to-do list. She can organize your closets, your life and now your gift-giving.  Lilly only bakes for 100 orders of her favourite Italian cookies,  so get yours in as soon as you can.  Just delicious and fresh. You really do not want to miss out on this opportunity.
Contact Lilly at:Info@rossiassistants.com  or call 514-915-3780

5Ital Cookies

Best Cookies on the West Island


This mother and daughter team took their traditional recipes to start their own business. A wide assortment of Italian style cookies are what you can expect at Ital Cookies.  From Nutella to sugar cookies and biscotti the assortment is just a phone call away.  Italian homemade cookies for all occasions: wedding/baby showers, birthday parties, holidays and sweet tables.
Call (514) 946-3705
Info: https://www.facebook.com/italcookies/